What happens when a charming, witty, (and brave!) rock star takes the reigns at a comedy show? The audience has one hell of an amazing night. Also charming our pants off for the evening were John Hodgman, Christian Finnegan, Jamie Lee, Harrison Greenbaum and Brandon Wardell–thank you for the fun. Now, may we please have our pants back?

Check out more photos from Monday’s Hot Tub HERE.

(Photos: Eric Michael Pearson, Ted Leo Photo: Marianne Ways)